Home › Guides › Water filters compared

Water filters and purification tablets compared

What you're protecting against, every treatment method compared for parasites, bacteria, viruses and chemicals, the types of filter, pore sizes and ratings explained, which to choose for home, grab bag, car, van or boat, and using a filter properly.

By Michael Johnson · Updated 18 November 2026 · How we check our guides

Water filter sales rose by 1,200% at one UK retailer in the week after the government's "Be Ready" campaign launched. But not all filters do the same job: most portable filters remove bacteria and parasites but not viruses, and none removes chemicals unless designed to. This guide compares gravity filters, straws, squeeze and pump filters, filter bottles, purification tablets and UV pens: what each removes, flow rates, costs, and which to choose for home emergencies, camping, vans and boats.

Short answer: for home emergencies, store bottled water first, then keep purification tablets (cheap, small, kill viruses) and, for longer outages, a gravity filter. Boiling is still the most reliable way to kill germs.

1. What you're protecting against

TypeExamplesSize
Protozoa (parasites)Giardia, CryptosporidiumAbout 1–15 microns
BacteriaE. coli, Salmonella, CampylobacterAbout 0.2–10 microns
VirusesNorovirus, hepatitis A, rotavirusAbout 0.02–0.3 microns: too small for most filters
ChemicalsFuel, pesticides, metals, industrial pollutionDissolved: need activated carbon or reverse osmosis, if removable at all

In the UK, US and Australia, streams and rainwater mostly carry bacteria and protozoa. Water contaminated by sewage or floodwater can carry viruses too.

2. Methods compared

MethodProtozoaBacteriaVirusesChemicals
Boiling (1 minute rolling boil)YesYesYesNo
Filter, 1 micron or smallerYesPartlyNoNo
Filter, 0.3 micron or smaller (most hollow-fibre filters are 0.1–0.2)YesYesNoNo
Purifier rated for viruses (very fine hollow-fibre or ultrafilter)YesYesYes (check the claim)No
Chlorine or iodine tabletsPoor against CryptosporidiumYesYesNo
Chlorine dioxide tabletsYes (Cryptosporidium needs up to 4 hours)YesYesNo
UV pen (clear water only)YesYesYesNo
Activated carbonNoNoNoSome (taste, chlorine, some chemicals)
Reverse osmosisYesYesYesMany

The most complete approach is to filter, then disinfect: a filter removes parasites and sediment, then tablets, UV or boiling deal with viruses.

3. Types of filter

TypeFlowCapacityGood for
Straw filterDrink directlyOften 1,000–4,000 LGrab bags; can't fill containers
Squeeze filterAbout 1 L per minuteOften very high with backflushingGrab bags, hiking, filling bottles
Filter bottleSip as you goHundreds to thousands of litresGrab bag, car
Pump filterAbout 1 L per minuteCeramic types can be cleaned many timesShallow or murky sources
Gravity bag filter1–2 L per minute, hands-freeHighFamilies, camps, vans
Countertop gravity filter (ceramic or carbon block)Several litres per hourThousands of litres per cartridgeHome emergencies, off-grid homes
Purification tablets30 minutes to 4 hours per batchOne tablet per 1 L (check pack)Every kit: small, cheap, kills viruses
UV penAbout 90 seconds per litreBattery-limitedClear water, travel

4. Pore sizes and ratings explained

5. Which to choose

SituationSuggestion
Home kit (mains outage)Stored water, purification tablets, and a gravity filter for longer outages
Grab bagSqueeze filter or filter bottle plus tablets
CarFilter bottle and tablets
Van or boatAn inline filter on the water system plus UV or tablets for drinking: see the off-grid water guide
Off-grid home on rainwater or a springSediment and carbon filters plus UV, and regular testing
Travel abroadA purifier rated for viruses, or filter plus tablets

6. Using a filter properly

7. Chemicals, floodwater and salt water

8. Frequently asked questions

Do water filters remove viruses?

Most portable filters (0.1–0.2 micron) don't. To deal with viruses, use a purifier with a tested virus claim, reverse osmosis, boiling, purification tablets or UV, ideally after filtering.

What is the best water filter for an emergency kit?

For a grab bag, a squeeze filter or filter bottle plus purification tablets. For home, stored water, tablets and a gravity filter for longer outages.

Are purification tablets better than a filter?

They kill viruses that filters miss, but don't remove sediment and are slow against some parasites. Filtering then using tablets covers the most.

Can I drink floodwater if I filter it?

No. Floodwater can carry sewage, fuel and chemicals that ordinary filters can't remove. Use stored or bottled water.

9. Sources

  1. US CDC, a guide to drinking water treatment and sanitation for backcountry and travel use: cdc.gov
  2. US CDC, how to make water safe in an emergency: cdc.gov
  3. Colorado State University Extension, guide to treating water in the backcountry: colostate.edu
  4. Yahoo Finance, freeze-dried meal and water filter sales after "Be Ready": yahoo.com

New to some of the terms? See the glossary. Not sure where to start? Try start here.