Composting toilets and off-grid waste: types, use and the rules
How waterless composting and separating toilets work, choosing one for a cabin, van or boat, installing and venting, daily use without smells, dealing with urine, emptying and finishing the compost, greywater, alternatives such as septic tanks, and the building, health and environmental rules in the UK, USA and Australia.
By Michael Johnson · Updated 17 November 2026 · How we check our guides
A composting or separating toilet lets you live off-grid, or use a cabin, van, boat or allotment, without a sewer, septic tank or water to flush. Done well, it doesn't smell, uses no water and produces a safe soil improver. Done badly, it smells, attracts flies and breaks environmental and planning rules. This guide covers the types, how to use and empty them, dealing with urine and greywater, and the rules for toilets and waste disposal in the UK, USA and Australia.
1. Types of waterless toilet
| Type | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Urine-diverting (separating) dry toilet | Urine is diverted to a bottle or soakaway; solids drop into a bucket or bag with cover material, which is emptied to an outside compost heap | Vans, boats, cabins, tiny homes; low cost |
| Self-contained composting toilet | Solids compost inside a heated or ventilated chamber with a mixer; emptied every few months | Cabins and homes with light to moderate use |
| Central (remote) composting system | Toilet upstairs drops into a large composting chamber below the floor | Permanent homes and public sites; often approved as a sewage system |
| Twin-vault or batch system | Two chambers used alternately; one rests and composts for a year while the other fills | Rural properties, eco-builds |
| Bucket (humanure) toilet | Bucket with sawdust; contents composted in a hot outdoor heap for a year or more | Temporary or very low-cost use; check local rules |
| Cassette / chemical toilet | Holding tank with chemicals; emptied at a chemical disposal point | Touring caravans and motorhomes (not composting) |
| Incinerating toilet | Burns waste to ash using electricity or gas | Cabins with good power; no compost to handle |
2. How composting works
Composting is decomposition by aerobic bacteria and fungi. They need:
- Moisture, but not too much: 40–60%, like a wrung-out sponge. Urine makes the mix too wet and smelly, so most modern toilets divert it.
- Carbon: sawdust, wood shavings, coir or peat-free cover material, balancing the nitrogen in faeces.
- Air: a vent fan, mixing or loose cover material.
- Time and warmth: pathogens die off with time (a year or more at normal temperatures) or heat (a hot compost heap at 55 °C+ for several days kills most).
Most small toilets don't fully compost the waste inside the unit; they dehydrate and start it. The contents then need secondary composting outside for 12 months or more before use.
3. Choosing one for a cabin, van or boat
- Capacity: check the maker's rating in "person-uses" or people for full-time use. A small unit for two people full-time may need emptying weekly.
- Urine separation: essential in vans and boats; makes everything else easier.
- Power: most have a 12 V fan drawing 0.1–0.3 A (2–7 Ah a day). Heated units can use 100–300 W, impractical off-grid. See the power consumption calculator.
- Size and access: make sure you can lift out the bin or bag and reach the urine bottle.
- Certification: for a permanent dwelling, look for a unit certified to the local standard (NSF/ANSI 41 in the US, AS/NZS 1546.2 in Australia), as many authorities require it.
4. Installing and venting
- Fit a vent pipe from the toilet to outside, with a small 12 V fan pulling air out. This keeps the room smell-free and dries the solids.
- Run the vent as directly as possible, terminating above the roof line or away from windows and doors; avoid long horizontal runs that collect condensation.
- In vans and boats, a through-wall or through-hull vent with a fly screen is common.
- Secure the toilet to the floor; in vehicles it must survive braking.
- If urine goes to a soakaway, keep it well away from wells, boreholes, watercourses and boundaries, and check local rules.
5. Daily use and avoiding smells
- Add a handful of cover material after each solid use.
- Sit to urinate (or use a separate urinal) so urine goes to the diverter, not the solids chamber.
- Keep the lid closed and the fan running.
- Toilet paper can usually go in the solids chamber; wipes, sanitary products and nappies can't.
- No chemicals, bleach or disinfectants in the chamber; they kill the composting organisms. Clean with vinegar and water.
- If it smells: it's usually too wet (urine getting in, not enough cover material) or the fan has stopped. Add dry material and check the diverter.
- Flies: keep the lid closed, use a fly screen on the vent, and add cover material promptly.
6. Dealing with urine
An adult produces about 1–1.5 litres of urine a day. Options:
- Bottle or tank: empty into a toilet, an approved disposal point or (where permitted) dilute and use on the garden. Rinse the bottle with water and a little vinegar to prevent urine scale.
- Soakaway: pipe to a gravel-filled soakaway or greywater system where local rules allow.
- Fertiliser: urine is rich in nitrogen. Diluted 1:10 with water, it can be used on non-food plants or around fruit trees. Stored for a month or more, it becomes much safer to handle.
7. Emptying and finishing the compost
- Wear gloves. Empty the bin or bag into a dedicated, covered compost bin, heap or bay, ideally a two- or three-bay system so you can rest one.
- Cover with more carbon material (straw, leaves, sawdust); turn occasionally if you want it to heat up.
- Leave it for at least 12 months after the last addition (longer in cold climates), or two years to be cautious.
- Use the finished compost around ornamental plants, trees or fruit trees, buried under soil. Many rules say at least 300 mm (12 in) of cover, and never on vegetables you eat.
- Keep compost heaps well away from water supplies, streams, wells and boundaries.
In vans and boats where you can't compost, solids bags can sometimes go in general waste if allowed by your local council and campsite; check first. Never empty solids into a chemical disposal point unless it's designed for it.
8. Greywater: the other half
A composting toilet only deals with toilet waste. Water from sinks, showers and washing machines (greywater) still needs a lawful disposal route: a septic tank, treatment plant, reed bed, soakaway or approved greywater system. Some authorities only approve a composting toilet if greywater is properly managed. Collecting rainwater for washing? See the off-grid water guide and the rainwater harvesting calculator.
9. Rules by country
United Kingdom
- Building Regulations: Approved Document G (sanitation) treats composting and chemical toilets as "earth closets" and refers to BS 6465-3 for guidance on selection and installation. A composting toilet can satisfy Part G in a new dwelling, but building control will usually expect a suitable design for disposal of the compost and greywater. Approved Document H covers drainage and wastewater.
- Environment: In England, discharges of sewage effluent (including greywater) to ground or water must meet the Environment Agency's general binding rules or have a permit; since 2020, septic tanks may not discharge directly to surface water. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own regulators (NRW, SEPA, NIEA).
- Planning: a composting toilet in a garden building or on an allotment usually doesn't need permission, but a new dwelling or change of use does.
- Boats: discharging toilet waste is banned on inland waterways; composting and separating toilets are popular on narrowboats, with solids disposed of according to Canal & River Trust guidance.
United States
- Rules are set by states and counties, usually through the health department or plumbing code. Many accept composting toilets certified to NSF/ANSI 41.
- Some states (for example Oregon, Massachusetts and Washington) have specific rules allowing composting toilets with a permit, while still requiring an approved greywater or septic system.
- Oregon's rules, for example, accept NSF 41 listed units, require an approved greywater route, and allow the composted end product only around non-food plants, buried under at least 12 inches of soil.
- Some lenders and insurers require a conventional septic system for a dwelling to be mortgageable.
Australia
- Waterless composting toilets are covered by AS/NZS 1546.2. In most states they must be an accredited or certified product, installed with council approval (in NSW, under section 68 of the Local Government Act, with NSW Health accreditation of the product).
- Councils typically issue an approval to install and an approval to operate, and set conditions such as minimum composting time (often 12 months), burial of compost on the property and greywater treatment.
- Greywater still needs an approved system or must go to a septic or treatment system.
10. Other options: septic tanks and treatment plants
| System | How it works | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Septic tank + drainage field | Settles solids; effluent soaks into the ground | Needs suitable soil and space; emptied every 1–3 years |
| Package treatment plant | Aerates and treats effluent to a higher standard | Needs power (50–150 W); can discharge where a septic tank can't |
| Cesspit / holding tank | Stores everything; tankered away | Expensive to empty frequently |
| Reed bed | Plants and gravel treat effluent from a tank | Low energy; needs space and design |
11. Frequently asked questions
Do composting toilets smell?
A well-run separating or composting toilet with a vent fan doesn't smell. Smells usually mean urine is getting into the solids, not enough cover material is being used, or the fan has stopped.
Are composting toilets legal in the UK?
Yes. Building Regulations Approved Document G recognises composting toilets, with guidance in BS 6465-3. For a new dwelling, building control will want a sensible disposal plan for the compost and greywater, and any discharge must meet environmental rules.
Are composting toilets legal in the US?
It depends on the state and county. Many accept units certified to NSF/ANSI 41 with a permit, but most still require an approved greywater or septic system for a dwelling.
Do I need council approval for a composting toilet in Australia?
Usually yes for a dwelling. Units should be accredited to AS/NZS 1546.2, and councils normally issue approvals to install and operate, with conditions on compost handling and greywater.
How often do you empty a composting toilet?
A small separating toilet used full-time by two people needs its solids bin emptied every 2–4 weeks and the urine bottle every 1–3 days. Larger self-contained units may go several months.
Can I use the compost on my vegetable garden?
It's not recommended. Use it around ornamental plants, trees or fruit trees, buried under soil, after at least 12 months of composting. Many rules prohibit using it on food crops.
12. Sources
- GOV.UK, Approved Document G (sanitation, hot water safety and water efficiency), 2024 amendments: gov.uk
- Planning Portal, Approved Document H (drainage and waste disposal): planningportal.co.uk
- Oregon Administrative Rules, OAR 918-770-0080 construction and installation of composting toilets: law.cornell.edu
- Greywater Action, greywater codes and policy: greywateraction.org
- NSW Health, waterless composting toilet accreditation guideline: health.nsw.gov.au
- Lismore City Council, waterless composting toilets: lismore.nsw.gov.au
- Standards Australia, AS/NZS 1546.2:2008 waterless composting toilets: standards.org.au
- BRANZ Level, composting toilets: level.org.nz
New to some of the terms? See the glossary. Not sure where to start? Try start here.